Reviews

As you all know we have received feedback on the STAR. We will not be part of Eurovis, however we have been selected for fast track to CGF. This means that our Eurovis reviews essentialy count as a first round of journal submission reviews.

Our Ratings were as follows:

R1 R2 R3 R4
Score BorderlineBorderlineAccept Reject

The text of the reviews can be foundhere

I have summarized the reviews and divided them into individual pooints in the following spreadsheet (shared via google Docs) Eurovis Star Feedback

The Goal is to assign responsibility for fixes in the spreadsheet, as well as keep track of other suggestions here:

R4 was the harshest, but provides also the best feedback

Meeting Notes 20180504

Suggestions